In Norse mythology, Hœnir (also Hǿnir; modern Icelandic Hænir, modern Swedish Höne) is one of the Æsir. Heis a very shadowy god figure in Norse mythology, who joins the gods Loki and Odin on a couple of occasions in the old texts. He seems to have attributes of creation and prophecy, and his name might advert a bond with birds, possibly birds of omen. He is mentioned in Vǫluspá as one of the three gods (along with Odin and Lóðurr) that created the first humans.
Attestations
In Völuspá, at the creation of the first human beings, Ask and Embla, Hœnir and Lóðurr help Odin. According to the Prose Edda, Hœnir is said to have given reason to man.
In Gylfaginning, Vili and Vé are mentioned instead. As Snorri Sturluson knew Völuspá, it is possible that Hœnir was another name for Vili. Also according to Völuspá, Hœnir was one of the few gods that would survive Ragnarök. In Ynglinga saga, along with Mímir, he went to the Vanir as a hostage to seal a truce after the Æsir-Vanir War. There, Hœnir was indecisive and relied on Mímir for all of his decisions, grunting noncommital answers when Mímir was absent.
We can infer very little from the remaining sources, but Hoenir is involved in at least one major mythological moment, namely the shaping of the first human beings, Ask and Embla, from two pieces of wood by bestowing essential gifts upon them. The myth is recounted in the Völuspá (Prophecy of the Seeress), the first poem in the mythological collection the Poetic Edda, in stanzas 17-18:
They had no breath,
they had no soul,
they had neither hair nor voice,
nor a good appearance.
Odin gave them breath,
Hoenir gave them a soul,
Lodur / Loki gave them hair
and a good appearance.
Here we have the first example of this trio of gods – Odin, Loki, Hoenir – completing each other’s deeds and capacities. Interestingly, Hoenir endows human beings with óð (accusative of óðr), a fascinating term that could mean mind, wit, sense, or inspiration as a noun and mad, frantic, or inspired as an adjective. It is the basic word from which the name Odin stems, so we cannot help wondering if there once existed a stronger link between the two, especially if the word refers to poetry. As for Loki as the other member of the party, in a poem named Háleygjatal preserved only in bits quoted in other works such as Icelandic chieftain and author Snorri’s poetic treaty Skáldskaparmál – part of the Prose Edda – Odin is described as Lodur’s friend, which reinforces the idea that Lodur from the passage in the Poetic Edda most likely is the same character, Loki.
On the other hand, in the first part of his Prose Edda called Gylfaginning (The Deluding of Gylfi) dealing with various aspects of Norse myth such as the creation and destruction of the world, Snorri wrote down a similar story but left Hoenir out of it. In his version, the creators seem to be the sons of Borr, namely Odin, Vili, and Vé. Vili gives them understanding and motion, thus leaving open the question of his equivalence to Hoenir. Or perhaps Snorri merely recorded another mythological tradition, as there was no true canon.
Return briefly to the Völuspá, when asked about Ragnarök, the twilight of the gods, the seeress usually mentions second-generation gods among the survivors, such as Odin’s sons Vidar and Baldr, or Thor’s sons Magni and Modi. However, the text adds Hoenir to the list, speaking of his skills in casting lots (hlautvið – twigs dipped in blood and shaken), which he will perform after the fields start growing again and the gods return.
Then Hoenir will be able
to choose his prophecies
and the two brothers,
the sons of the Two-Fold (Odin)
will dwell in the heavens.
Do you want to know more, Allfather?
(stanza 63)
These divination skills might lead one to think of a priestly function. Snorri, however, leaves Hoenir out of his account of Ragnarök.
Besides Odin, a few clues hint at an important connection to Loki as well. In an old skaldic poem – skalds being composers honouring the deeds of patrons or tackling broader topics in verses with complicated metre and heavy figurative speech – called “Autumn-Long” (Old Norse: Haustlǫng) written by Thjodolf of Hvin in the 9th century, Loki is described as “Hoenir’s friend” and “the tester of Hoenir’s mind.” In the first 13 stanzas, the mythologically rich poem recounts the encounter of the same trio – Odin, Loki, and Hoenir – with the giant Thjazi, shaped like an eagle. As they are trying to cook some ox meat, the bird desires part of the meal to which Loki reacts by hitting it with his staff, which gets stuck, and the eagle flies off with him. In exchange for his retrieval, Thjazi demands Idunn, a goddess of youth. Once more, we can notice the enigmatic nature of Hoenir, as it is Loki who dominates the mythical scenes.
In the Reginsmál (The Lay of Regin) is another context where Hoenir appears in this group of three divinities, a piece which belongs to the heroic tradition in the Poetic Edda, namely a series of poems dealing with the material which in the late 13th century would become the Saga of the Volsungs. This legendary saga deals among other things with the hero Sigurd, who after killing the dragon Fafnir becomes the owner of the cursed treasure including the ring Andvaranaut, which will eventually bring him to his doom. After the death of his father Sigmund and his mother’s marriage into another royal family, Sigurd gets a teacher called Regin while at court, who convinces him to pursue the treasure after telling him his otherworldly story. His father Hreidmar had three sons, himself, a skilled metalworker, Otr, an otter-shaped fisherman, and Fafnir, the fiercest. One day out fishing, the gods Odin, Loki, and Hoenir kill Otr in his animal shape, skinning and eating him. After demanding compensation by filling the skin with gold, Loki goes after the gold of the dwarf Andvari to pay Hreidmar. Fafnir will eventually turn into a dragon after killing his father and amassing all the cursed treasure. In the prose prologue of the poem Reginsmál these events are briefly mentioned, yet we get nothing more than the god’s name in the trio of gods who commit the crime.
In the Ynglinga Saga – the mythological prehistory of Snorri’s chronicle of the Norwegian kings where the kings trace their lineage back to the Swedish Ynglings, in their turn descended from the gods – Snorri mentions that in the exchange of hostages that occurs between the two main families of gods, the Æsir and the Vanir, as a pledge of goodwill, Hoenir is sent from the Æsir to the Vanir along with Mimir. As they realise they were cheated because Hoenir only relies on the counsel of Mimir thus being unsuitable as a chieftain, they behead Mimir and send him back to Odin. By preserving the head of this wise creature, Odin gains access to secret knowledge, a skill indirectly made possible by Hoenir. It appears that Hoenir might have returned among the Æsir, as the Gylfaginning mentions that the god Njord is exchanged for Hoenir in the settlement, and in another section of Snorri’s Edda, he also takes part in a banquet of the Æsir. Furthermore, the story in the Ynglinga Saga is quite different from the one in the Prose Edda, the latter probably sticking closer to the mythical ‘originals’.
A rather exotic occurrence of Hoenir can be found not in an Icelandic source but in a Faroese ballad from a 19th-century manuscript and probably dating back to the Middle Ages. A Tale of Loki (Loka Táttur) presents the story of a man who loses a bet with a giant, who then claims his son. To avoid this tragedy, the farmer resorts to the standard trio of Odin, Loki, and Hoenir. After Odin fails to hide him as a grain in a field, Hoenir turns him into a feather on a swan’s head but calls the boy back as he sees the giant wrenching the swan’s head. The boy is finally saved by Loki’s cunning intervention.
In most of these mythological fragments, Hoenir seems well-connected with Loki and Odin, yet the underlying reasons evade us. It might be that since Loki is always the cunning, talkative, and active one, Hoenir might be used as a contrast, to embody another principle – perhaps the silent, feeble, passive nature.
Lastly, the root of Hoenir’s name reminds us of chickens. If høna is “hen,” could Hoenir (Hønir in other spellings) be the “gatherer of hens”? In the description of the apocalypse in the Völuspá, we encounter roosters heralding its beginnings. Or could it rather mean the “slayer of hens”? In this case, we could speculate about the metaphor for a hawk, a bird associated with Odin and Loki. Furthermore, Snorri suggests in his poetic treaty, the Skáldskaparmál, to use metaphors (kenningar) such as Odin’s companion, long-foot, swift god, or mud-king in reference to Hoenir. These metaphors regarding motion stand in harmony with the fact that, in the creation myth, he offers humans sense or motion. By giving them a soul, they become moving, alive.
All in all, there are more unanswered than answered questions: Why is he the mud-king (aurkonungr)? Aurr is not only wet clay, it is also the purling water with foam of the well of Urd at the roots of the world-tree Yggdrassil, the well where the Norns sat and decided the fate of humans and gods. This could hint at the god’s fortune-telling abilities. And the long foot? Long legs and walking in mud leads us to think of storks, so birds again, birds that many times occur as companions of gods and bearers of omens. One of Zeus’ nicknames is the swan-like god of heaven, making us wonder about the higher role of Hoenir and its fading away over time.
Kennings describe him as “swift god,” “long-legged,” and “mud- or marsh-king” (aurkonungr, the first element of which is difficult to interpret). He was also called “the most fearful of all the gods.”
By far the best-known reference to Hoenir in Old Norse literature comes from the Ynglinga Saga, a work of the notoriously unreliable Snorri Sturluson. In Snorri’s version of the Aesir-Vanir War, the Aesir and Vanir tribes of deities exchanged hostages. The Aesir sent the Vanir Hoenir and Mimir. The Vanir were so impressed by Hoenir’s handsomeness that they made him their chieftain. However, Hoenir was dim-witted and indecisive, and was incapable of issuing a decision without Mimir first telling him what decision he should make. When Mimir was away and others pressed him for a decision, he would just say, “Let others decide.” When the Vanir noticed this pattern, they thought the Aesir had cheated them in their hostage exchange, and they angrily beheaded Mimir and sent the decapitated head back to the Aesir.[5] Needless to say, this portrait of Hoenir as a witless, timid idiot is impossible to reconcile with his portrayals throughout the rest of Old Norse literature.
These various portrayals of Hoenir don’t present any particularly consistent picture of him. If we toss out Snorri’s depiction of him, the picture becomes less confused, but hardly clear. It seems reasonably certain that he was powerfully connected to Odin and possessed many of Odin’s characteristics and abilities. Perhaps, as in the Völuspá, he was a nominally distinct extension of Odin, like Hermod and various other minor Norse gods. But in the absence of any more substantial evidence, such a suggestion can only be tentative.
In Völuspá, we find out that Hoenir is to be one of the few gods who survives Ragnarök.
Thoughts on Hœnir
In the lore, Hoenir seems to vacillate between useless tit and important creator. Just as with so many other poorly attested gods, we may never know for certain what his role in the Norse pantheon actually was, or if he had different roles depending on the location and culture within which he was acknowledged.
It seems as though Snorri took great care to include Hoenir in his writings, where other gods and characters were afforded little more than a line or two, so it’s tempting to assume that he was a very important god at one time. Snorri definitely had access to the Poetic Edda, as he borrowed heavily from it, so we know that the creation story involving Hoenir was also known to him. So why did he write the same story with different names – Vili and Vé? Why use Hoenir’s name in a different story altogether, and dumb him down? It may have simply been poetic license on Snorri’s part.
I think it’s important to remember that Snorri was, at heart, a poet and creative writer, as well as a Christian – and so it makes sense that the lore he presents is filled with exaggerations, characters altered to suit his purposes, and verbal bridges linking disparate mythologies from different cultural centres and different timelines. He started with a bunch of vaguely related, conflicting myths and sat down to write a story that his contemporary readers could understand. He had a great love of the mythologies, but no great motivation to record them exactly as they were.
There are some elements of Hoenir’s various stories that do make sense. If he was Óðin’s brother, he would have made a grand and honourable trade for the Vanir fertility gods, along with Mímir, who was already well respected for his great wisdom. Along with his peers, Hoenir would have been worshiped more, or less, and given different attributes according to where in the world he was being worshiped, so the fact that the stories paint wildly different pictures of him isn’t such a surprise after all.
I mean, we’re talking about a culture that put Óðin at the head of the pantheon in Germany, Óðin as Woden in the Saxon lands, Freyr as chief in Sweden, and then Thor – renamed as Perun and given an axe instead of a hammer – as the chief in some of the Slavic lands. In the end, we are left to decide for ourselves and create our own portrait of Hoenir, just as Snorri was.
Signs and Symbols:
Perhaps personal symbols that represent inspiration or decisiveness would bring Hoenir’s influence into your practice. A piece of Ash or Elm as a reminder of his gifts to the first man and woman.
Hildebrand, K. (ed.), Bellows, H. (tr.). Old Norse Poetic Edda Diglot. Melbourne, 2011
Jonsson, F. (ed.). De gamle Eddadigte . G.E.C. Gads Forlag, Copenhagen, 1932
Lindow, John. Norse Mythology. Oxford University Press, 2002.
Sturluson, Snorri & Faulkes, Anthony. Edda. Viking Society for Northern Research, 2005.
Sturluson, Snorri. Heimskringla. Viking Society for Northern Research, 1970.
https://www.worldhistory.org/Hoenir/
https://norse-mythology.org/hoenir/
http://ydalir.ca/norsegods/hoenir/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H%C5%93nir
No responses yet